Axanar accused the producers of Star Trek–Horizon of having bought YouTube views of its trailer, and suggested the count for the film itself was inflated.

In a tweet August 20, 2016, Axanar’s Twitter account posted:

Axanar @axanar You would have to compare real stats not views that Horizon bought, like its 3m views for its trailer.

The tweet came a few days after AxaMonitor observed dozens of duplicate tweets from dummy accounts pointing people to Axanar’s short film, Prelude to Axanar, and after AxaMonitor published an article by editor Carlos Pedraza, “Why Horizon's Success Matters.”

PURCHASED VIEWS While Axanar accuses Horizon of buying 3.4 million views for its trailer, YouTube data since 2014 show only a burst of activity upon its release and just prior to the film’s February 2016 release. (Click to view full size.)

The article noted that Horizon was due to surpass Prelude‘s 2.5 million views by August 24, challenging Axanar producer Alec Peters’ characterization of Prelude as “the most successful Trek film ever”¹⁾ — “by any metric,” added director Robert Meyer Burnett.²⁾

It took Prelude two years to accumulate its views; Horizon took five months. Asked to provide evidence for its accusation against Horizon, the Axanar Twitter account instead wrote:

Axanar @startrekaxanar Simply compare stats - Views/likes/comments. You can’t have same # of views & 1/2 the comments & likes.³⁾

Misty Mills @mistymills Not really a good metric. Last stat I heard was only ~52% of YouTube users even use commenting.

Axanar didn’t tweet further on the topic of evidence at the time this article was posted.

For his part, Burnett refused to identify which metrics justified his claim of most successful: “Nobody cares how many views Prelude to Axanar has on YouTube … except you,” Burnett told AxaMonitor.⁴⁾

NIPPING AT THE HEELS of Prelude to Axanar‘s astonishing viewership is upstart fan film Star Trek–Horizon, projected to surpass Prelude‘s views on August 23. (Click icon to view full size)

@AxaMonitor: “Seriously though, I’m interested in the metrics you used in claiming Prelude to Axanar is the most successful fan film.”
@BurnettRM: I leave that up to you.
@AxaMonitor: So. Just boast, and then … “We do not discuss it with outsiders…”?
@BurnettRM: C’mon now…you’re the expert…again…I ask..what do YOU think?⁵⁾

When asked why he made the boast if he wasn’t going to substantiate it, Burnett tweeted, “So people who might not watch the film will tune in and see for themselves. That’s showmanship. That’s Hollywood.”⁶⁾ [emphasis added]

Asked on Twitter if he believed Axanar’s accusation against Horizon⁷⁾, Burnett remained silent. AxaMonitor was unable to reach Horizon producer Tommy Kraft for his reaction.

As of this posting⁸⁾, Prelude to Axanar had logged 2,557,472 views; Star Trek–Horizon had 2,518,020. Both Star Trek–Horizon and Prelude to Axanar are available on YouTube.

Keywords