Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
todd_dragoncon [2017/09/02 23:29] – [Dragon*Con Response] adds tags Carlos Pedrazatodd_dragoncon [2018/06/17 12:46] (current) – [Doubtful Independence] adds link Carlos Pedraza
Line 8: Line 8:
 </WRAP> </WRAP>
  
-ATLANTA — Exactly two years after Tony Todd left Axanar doubting producer Alec Peters' accountability for more than a million dollars of fans' money, the production and its fans continued to use his image to sell merchandise. Todd was not pleased.+ATLANTA — Exactly two years after Tony Todd left Axanar doubting producer Alec Peters' accountability for more than a million dollars of fans' money, some fans continued to use his image to sell merchandise made by Axanar Productions. Todd was not pleased.
  
 ===== Dragon*Con Banner ===== ===== Dragon*Con Banner =====
Line 14: Line 14:
 An Axanar fan table in Atlanta's Hilton Hotel as part of the large Dragon*Con convention in September 2017 prominently featured a banner with Todd's picture under the title "Axanar," the never-to-be-produced feature film Todd [[tony_todd|walked away from]] in September 2015. An Axanar fan table in Atlanta's Hilton Hotel as part of the large Dragon*Con convention in September 2017 prominently featured a banner with Todd's picture under the title "Axanar," the never-to-be-produced feature film Todd [[tony_todd|walked away from]] in September 2015.
  
-[{{ :todd-twitter.jpg?250|**Actor Tony Todd on [[twit>TonyTodd54|Twitter]]**}}]+<WRAP round tip> 
 +{{::fan-table-gone.jpg|}} \\ 
 +<wrap lo><wrap em>UPDATE</wrap> The day after this article was posted, the Axanar fan table was no longer operating at Dragon*Con.</wrap> 
 +</WRAP> 
 + 
 +[{{ :tony-todd.jpg?300|**Actor Tony Todd on [[twit>TonyTodd54|Twitter]]**}}]
  
 <WRAP> <WRAP>
Line 24: Line 29:
 Todd left Axanar in September 2015,(([[http://www.prlog.org/12489801-tony-todd-exits-star-trek-axanar.html|PRLog press release, "Tony Todd Exits Star Trek Axanar"]], 9/1/15.)) though his departure from the project was not publicly acknowledged by Axanar producer Alec Peters for several months, even though Todd’s photo remained a prominent part of Axanar’s ongoing Indiegogo campaign. Todd left Axanar in September 2015,(([[http://www.prlog.org/12489801-tony-todd-exits-star-trek-axanar.html|PRLog press release, "Tony Todd Exits Star Trek Axanar"]], 9/1/15.)) though his departure from the project was not publicly acknowledged by Axanar producer Alec Peters for several months, even though Todd’s photo remained a prominent part of Axanar’s ongoing Indiegogo campaign.
  
-Indeed, despite Todd's two-year-old [[tony_todd|disavowal]] of the long-delayed project and Peters himself, the actor's image continued to appear prominently on Axanar Productions' homepage throughout the lawsuit and even until September 2017.+<wrap lo>//See also: [[tony_todd|Why Tony Todd left Axanar and why it took so long for fans to find out]]//</wrap>
  
-[{{::todd-prelude-actors.jpg|**DISAVOWAL** Star Trek actor Tony Todd (second from left) still appeared on Axanar's homepage when this screenshot was taken on September 2, 2017, despite his condemnation of the project and its producer, Alec Peters, }}]+Indeed, despite Todd's two-year-old [[tony_todd|disavowal]] of the long-delayed project and Peters himself, the actor's image continued to appear prominently on Axanar Productions' homepage throughout the lawsuit and even until September 2017.
  
 +[{{::todd-prelude-actors.jpg|**DISAVOWAL** Star Trek actor Tony Todd (second from right) still appeared on Axanar's homepage when this screenshot was taken on September 2, 2017, despite his condemnation of the project and its producer, Alec Peters.}}]
 ===== Todd's Image 'Not Affiliated' with Axanar ===== ===== Todd's Image 'Not Affiliated' with Axanar =====
  
Line 39: Line 45:
  
 Axanar spokesman Mike Bawden added, "As for Tony Todd's complaint over the use of his likeness to promote a project on which he worked, we have no comment."((Mike Bawden email to AxaMonitor editor Carlos Pedraza, 9/2/17.)) Axanar spokesman Mike Bawden added, "As for Tony Todd's complaint over the use of his likeness to promote a project on which he worked, we have no comment."((Mike Bawden email to AxaMonitor editor Carlos Pedraza, 9/2/17.))
-==== Independent Doubts ====+==== Doubtful Independence ====
  
 However, Axanar's supposed lack of affiliation with the fan group appeared doubtful given: However, Axanar's supposed lack of affiliation with the fan group appeared doubtful given:
  
-/* [{{ ::peters-dragoncon-todd.jpg?direct&400|**UNTROUBLED** by the continued use of actor Tony Todd's image in a banner that could only have been created by Axanar and provided to the fan group, Axanar producer Alec Peters poses at the fan table with his girlfriend, Crysstal Hubbard.}}] +[{{ ::peters-dragoncon-todd.jpg?direct&400|**UNTROUBLED** by the continued use of actor Tony Todd's image in a banner that could only have been created by Axanar and provided to the fan group, Axanar producer Alec Peters poses at the fan table with his girlfriend, Crysstal Hubbard.}}]
-*/+
  
-  * **Merchandise** on display and for sale, all of which come from Axanar's Donor Store. While Peters had announced the formation of independent Axanar fan groups around the country, he never disclosed that he had given them his remaining stock of merchandise.+  * **Merchandise** on display and for sale, all of which came from Axanar's [[merchandise|Donor Store]]. While Peters had announced the formation of independent Axanar fan groups around the country, he never disclosed that he had given them his remaining stock of merchandise. That stock had been manufactured using donors' money that was supposed to have gone toward making the film.
   * **Banner** Professionally printed, displaying the Axanar logo, not the logo of an "independent" organization.   * **Banner** Professionally printed, displaying the Axanar logo, not the logo of an "independent" organization.
-  * **Earnings** Apart from a portion of proceeds from sales of one of the patches supposedly destined for "animal charities," the allegedly independent fan group did not disclose what it would be doing with the money it was making from sales of merchandise that could only have been supplied by Axanar itself. Even the so-called charitable effort broke Dragon*Con's own rules governing fan tables (see [[#no sales for charity]]). +  * **Earnings** Apart from a portion of proceeds from sales of one of the patches supposedly destined for "animal charities," the allegedly independent fan group did not disclose what it would be doing with the money it was making from sales of merchandise that could only have been supplied by Axanar itself. Even the purported charitable effort broke Dragon*Con's own rules governing fan tables (see [[#no sales for charity]]). 
-  * **Peters' participation** at the fan table; he and his girlfriend, Crysstal Hubbard, posed for at least one photo right in front of Todd's image. He appeared untroubled by the use of Todd's photo.+  * **Peters' participation** at the fan table; he posed for photos right in front of Todd's image. He appeared untroubled by the use of Todd's photo.
  
 ===== Selling Merchandise ===== ===== Selling Merchandise =====
Line 61: Line 66:
 Yet there at the fan table was a sign labeled "Axanar Swag" advertising patches on sale for $8-$24. Sales of the patches appeared to go against the convention's rules about selling merchandise at fan tables. According to Dragon*Con's website: Yet there at the fan table was a sign labeled "Axanar Swag" advertising patches on sale for $8-$24. Sales of the patches appeared to go against the convention's rules about selling merchandise at fan tables. According to Dragon*Con's website:
  
-> Fan Tables are generally non-profit groups organized by members of a particular fandom or convention. … In deference to our dealers and exhibitors who purchase a table or sponsor the convention, <wrap hi>no general merchandise sales are permitted at concourse tables</wrap>. You may sell items imprinted with your organization’s name or logo only, such as pins, t-shirts, or bookmarks."(([[http://www.dragoncon.org/?q=fan_application_form|DRAGON CON 2017 - FAN TABLE APPLICATION FORM]], retrieved 9/2/17.)) [emphasis theirs]+> Fan Tables are generally non-profit groups organized by members of a particular fandom or convention. … In deference to our dealers and exhibitors who purchase a table or sponsor the convention, <wrap hi>no general merchandise sales are permitted at concourse tables</wrap>. You may sell items imprinted with your organization’s name or logo only, such as pins, t-shirts, or bookmarks.(([[http://www.dragoncon.org/?q=fan_application_form|Dragon Con 2017 – Fan Table Application Form]], retrieved 9/2/17.)) [emphasis theirs]
  
 [{{ ::no_logo_axanar_fan_club.jpg?direct&400|**NO LOGO** Despite the Axanar fan club's claims its merchandise was cleared for sale by Dragon*Con, the items did not feature either the fan club's name or logo as required by the convention's rules, only that of the ostensibly unaffiliated Axanar Productions.}}] [{{ ::no_logo_axanar_fan_club.jpg?direct&400|**NO LOGO** Despite the Axanar fan club's claims its merchandise was cleared for sale by Dragon*Con, the items did not feature either the fan club's name or logo as required by the convention's rules, only that of the ostensibly unaffiliated Axanar Productions.}}]
Line 71: Line 76:
 > Lee Benjamin has said he cleared the sale of items with Dragon*Con.  [The convention] has said “General merchandise”  means merchandise for sale in the dealers room, and organisations are allowed to sell items relating to their specific clubs.((Mike Bawden email to AxaMonitor editor Carlos Pedraza, 9/2/17.)) > Lee Benjamin has said he cleared the sale of items with Dragon*Con.  [The convention] has said “General merchandise”  means merchandise for sale in the dealers room, and organisations are allowed to sell items relating to their specific clubs.((Mike Bawden email to AxaMonitor editor Carlos Pedraza, 9/2/17.))
  
-That didn't appear to comport with Dragon*Con's actual definition, which defined allowable sales only for items "imprinted with your organization’s name or logo."(([[http://www.dragoncon.org/?q=fan_application_form|DRAGON CON 2017 - FAN TABLE APPLICATION FORM]], retrieved 9/2/17.))+That didn't appear to comport with Dragon*Con's actual definition, which defined allowable sales only for items "imprinted with your organization’s name or logo."(([[http://www.dragoncon.org/?q=fan_application_form|Dragon Con 2017 – Fan Table Application Form]], retrieved 9/2/17.))
  
 ==== Disclosing Affiliation ==== ==== Disclosing Affiliation ====
Line 79: Line 84:
 === No Sales for Charity === === No Sales for Charity ===
  
-Dragon*Con's rules also stipulate fan tables cannot collect money for charities. The Axanar "Boomer Patch" depicting the cat, Boomer, owned by Peters' former girlfriend, [[Diana Kingsbury]] — a sort of mascot for the project — was selling at the Axanar table for $8, half of which was to go to unnamed "animal charities." Dragon*Con's fan table rules state:+Dragon*Con's rules also stipulate fan tables cannot collect money for charities. The Axanar "Boomer Patch" depicting the cat, Boomer, owned by Axanar's fulfillment director and Peters' former girlfriend, [[perks|Diana Kingsbury]] — a sort of mascot for the project — was selling at the Axanar table for $8, half of which was to go to unnamed "animal charities." Dragon*Con's fan table rules state:
  
-> <wrap hi>Charity collections are not allowed</wrap> at Concourse Tables as it may interfere with the integrity of the Dragon Con approved and sponsored charity.([[http://www.dragoncon.org/?q=fan_application_form|DRAGON CON 2017 - FAN TABLE APPLICATION FORM]], retrieved 9/2/17.))+> <wrap hi>Charity collections are not allowed</wrap> at Concourse Tables as it may interfere with the integrity of the Dragon Con approved and sponsored charity.(([[http://www.dragoncon.org/?q=fan_application_form|Dragon Con 2017 – Fan Table Application Form]], retrieved 9/2/17.))
  
 ===== Deflecting Criticism ===== ===== Deflecting Criticism =====