Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision
Previous revision
prelude_awards [2018/02/05 11:30] – adds new material regarding percentage of Axa awards from these award events Carlos Pedrazaprelude_awards [2020/09/12 17:13] (current) Carlos Pedraza
Line 1: Line 1:
 {{::awards_only_have_meaning_and_merit_if_they_are_hard_to_get.jpg|}} {{::awards_only_have_meaning_and_merit_if_they_are_hard_to_get.jpg|}}
-<wrap lo>//As many as one-third of //Prelude to Axanar//'s awards are from "award events," a term used by film festival submission site Film Freeway to distinguish them from legitimate film festivals.// <wrap lo><wrap indent>Image/Film Freeway</wrap></wrap></wrap>+<wrap lo>//As many as 35 percent of //Prelude to Axanar//'s awards are from "award events," a term used by film festival submission site Film Freeway to distinguish them from traditional film festival competitions.// <wrap lo><wrap indent>Image/Film Freeway</wrap></wrap></wrap>
  
 ====== The Story Behind Prelude to Axanar's ‘47 Awards’ ====== ====== The Story Behind Prelude to Axanar's ‘47 Awards’ ======
Line 8: Line 8:
 {{TOC}} {{TOC}}
 <WRAP> <WRAP>
-//**__ __**// <wrap lo>**By [[user>cpedraza|Carlos Pedraza]]**</wrap>+//**__<wrap em>Analysis</wrap>__**// \\ 
 +<wrap lo>**By [[user>cpedraza|Carlos Pedraza]]**</wrap>
 </WRAP> </WRAP>
  
Line 16: Line 17:
  
 > If you have to say "award-winning" in front of your name, chances are those awards are meaningless. Because if your awards mean something, they have a name everyone recognizes, like "Academy Award winner" or "Golden Globe winner."(({{:alec_awards.jpg?linkonly|Alec Peters post on his personal Facebook page}}, 1/1/18.)) > If you have to say "award-winning" in front of your name, chances are those awards are meaningless. Because if your awards mean something, they have a name everyone recognizes, like "Academy Award winner" or "Golden Globe winner."(({{:alec_awards.jpg?linkonly|Alec Peters post on his personal Facebook page}}, 1/1/18.))
 +
 +[{{ :alec_peters.jpg?nolink&100|**Alec Peters**}}]
  
 ===== Award Winners 'Delusional' ===== ===== Award Winners 'Delusional' =====
Line 23: Line 26:
 > So when you say on your LinkedIn that you are "an award-winning writer & producer" and your awards are from competitions no one has heard of, for projects no one has heard of, you are deluding yourself.(({{:alec_awards.jpg?linkonly|Alec Peters post on his personal Facebook page}}, 1/1/18.)) > So when you say on your LinkedIn that you are "an award-winning writer & producer" and your awards are from competitions no one has heard of, for projects no one has heard of, you are deluding yourself.(({{:alec_awards.jpg?linkonly|Alec Peters post on his personal Facebook page}}, 1/1/18.))
  
-<WRAP right round important 50%>+<WRAP right round important 320px>
 <wrap lo>**How Many Awards Did //Prelude// Actually Win?** <wrap lo>**How Many Awards Did //Prelude// Actually Win?**
 {{ ::oie_transparent-3.png?nolink&150|}} {{ ::oie_transparent-3.png?nolink&150|}}
Line 46: Line 49:
 ==== Meaningful Awards ==== ==== Meaningful Awards ====
  
-Moreover, how do //Prelude//'s own awards stack to Peters' own definition of a meaningful award, that they are won from festivals "everyone recognizes"?+Moreover, how do //Prelude//'s own awards stack up to Peters' own definition of a meaningful award, that they are won from festivals "everyone recognizes"?
  
 ===== Suspect Festivals and Awards  ===== ===== Suspect Festivals and Awards  =====
Line 52: Line 55:
 Of //Prelude//'s 45 awards, which came from festivals "everyone recognizes"?(({{:alec_awards.jpg?linkonly|Alec Peters post on his personal Facebook page}}, 1/1/18.)) Arguably, none. More importantly, however, some of the awards came from festivals that aren't even really film festivals as most people think of them (i.e., an event where films are screened in theaters before audiences and juries, both of which vote to grant awards to a small number of the participating movies). Of //Prelude//'s 45 awards, which came from festivals "everyone recognizes"?(({{:alec_awards.jpg?linkonly|Alec Peters post on his personal Facebook page}}, 1/1/18.)) Arguably, none. More importantly, however, some of the awards came from festivals that aren't even really film festivals as most people think of them (i.e., an event where films are screened in theaters before audiences and juries, both of which vote to grant awards to a small number of the participating movies).
  
-<WRAP right round important 50%>+<WRAP right round important 320px>
 {{ ::linkedin-transparent.png?nolink&50|}} {{ ::linkedin-transparent.png?nolink&50|}}
 <wrap lo>**DISCLOSURE** Though Alec Peters named no particular filmmaker in his anti-awards rant on Facebook, it is possible he was referring to **AxaMonitor** editor and independent filmmaker Carlos Pedraza, whose LinkedIn profile summary describes him as an "award-winning writer [and] producer."</wrap>(([[https://www.linkedin.com/in/carlospedraza/|Carlos Pedraza LinkedIn profile]], retrieved 2/4/18.)) <wrap lo>**DISCLOSURE** Though Alec Peters named no particular filmmaker in his anti-awards rant on Facebook, it is possible he was referring to **AxaMonitor** editor and independent filmmaker Carlos Pedraza, whose LinkedIn profile summary describes him as an "award-winning writer [and] producer."</wrap>(([[https://www.linkedin.com/in/carlospedraza/|Carlos Pedraza LinkedIn profile]], retrieved 2/4/18.))
 </WRAP> </WRAP>
  
-==== One-Third of 'Prelude's Awards ====+==== More Than One-Third of 'Prelude's Awards ====
  
-Of the 45 confirmed awards won by //Prelude//, 15 (or one-third) came from sources that didn't appear to be traditional film festivals but rather what some in the industry refer to as "award factories."((Bears Fonte, [[http://www.otherworldsaustin.com/blog/2017/7/18/film-festivals-vs-award-factories-vs-film-festivals-that-give-out-10000-awards|"Film Festivals vs. Award Factories vs. Film Festivals That Give Out 10,000 Awards"]], Out in Austin festival website, 7/18/17.))+Of the 45 confirmed awards won by //Prelude//, 16 (or 35 percent) came from sources that didn't appear to be traditional film festivals but rather what some in the industry refer to as "award factories."((Bears Fonte, [[http://www.otherworldsaustin.com/blog/2017/7/18/film-festivals-vs-award-factories-vs-film-festivals-that-give-out-10000-awards|"Film Festivals vs. Award Factories vs. Film Festivals That Give Out 10,000 Awards"]], Out in Austin festival website, 7/18/17.))
  
 ==== 'Award Factories' ==== ==== 'Award Factories' ====
  
-Instead, 10 of the festivals granting awards to //Prelude// appear to be what are known in filmmaking circles as "award events," in which filmmakers submit their work and getting one of many awards — all for at least one fee, sometimes more.  The film festival submission site, [[http://filmfreeway.com|Film Freeway]], has a special category devoted to these to distinguish them from traditional film festivals.+Ten of the 24 festivals granting awards to //Prelude// appear to be what are known in filmmaking circles as "award events," in which filmmakers submit their work and getting one of many awards — all for at least one fee, sometimes more.  That's 42 percent of the festivals or "award events" from which //Prelude// received honors. 
 + 
 +The film festival submission site, [[http://filmfreeway.com|Film Freeway]], has a special category, "Online Festivals / Awards Events," devoted to these award sources to distinguish them from traditional film festivals. 
 + 
 +---- 
 +<WRAP> 
 +//**__« A high quantity of awards diminishes its impact and often feels more like a bait to reel in filmmakers. »__**// <wrap indent>— //Film Festival Founder Henry Wong//</wrap> 
 +</WRAP>
  
 Film journalist and director of the scifi festival Out in Austin, Bears Fonte, goes so far as to deride such events as "awards factories [with] names that sound legitimate enough, like including 'International Film Festival' in the title. Many even claim they have Live Screenings … but a quick jaunt to their website reveals very little about these screenings, where they are and what sort of attendance is there."((Bears Fonte, [[http://www.otherworldsaustin.com/blog/2017/7/18/film-festivals-vs-award-factories-vs-film-festivals-that-give-out-10000-awards|"Film Festivals vs. Award Factories vs. Film Festivals That Give Out 10,000 Awards"]], Out in Austin festival website, 7/18/17.)) Film journalist and director of the scifi festival Out in Austin, Bears Fonte, goes so far as to deride such events as "awards factories [with] names that sound legitimate enough, like including 'International Film Festival' in the title. Many even claim they have Live Screenings … but a quick jaunt to their website reveals very little about these screenings, where they are and what sort of attendance is there."((Bears Fonte, [[http://www.otherworldsaustin.com/blog/2017/7/18/film-festivals-vs-award-factories-vs-film-festivals-that-give-out-10000-awards|"Film Festivals vs. Award Factories vs. Film Festivals That Give Out 10,000 Awards"]], Out in Austin festival website, 7/18/17.))
Line 84: Line 94:
 > The number of filmmakers I’ve met that have blindly spent hundreds of dollars on film festivals that bore no fruit is astounding. You can Google “scam film festivals” and find a ton of horror stories. There are no showings that I can see for this first batch, though many claim to have "on-line" showings. One promises to have your film screened for distribution execs and sent out a press release on your win … for a small additional fee."((Henry Wong, [[https://inkspire.org/post/scam-festivals-signs-of-a-fake-film-festival/-KqebuOXEPf-0fTG6vRd|"Scam Festivals: Signs of a Fake Film Festival"]], Inkspire website, 1/10/18.)) > The number of filmmakers I’ve met that have blindly spent hundreds of dollars on film festivals that bore no fruit is astounding. You can Google “scam film festivals” and find a ton of horror stories. There are no showings that I can see for this first batch, though many claim to have "on-line" showings. One promises to have your film screened for distribution execs and sent out a press release on your win … for a small additional fee."((Henry Wong, [[https://inkspire.org/post/scam-festivals-signs-of-a-fake-film-festival/-KqebuOXEPf-0fTG6vRd|"Scam Festivals: Signs of a Fake Film Festival"]], Inkspire website, 1/10/18.))
  
-<WRAP right round todo 50%>+<WRAP right round todo 320px>
 [{{ :jody-wheeler.jpg?nolink&100|**Jody Wheeler**}}] [{{ :jody-wheeler.jpg?nolink&100|**Jody Wheeler**}}]
 <wrap lo>**HOW AWARD FACTORIES WORK** \\ <wrap lo>**HOW AWARD FACTORIES WORK** \\
Line 100: Line 110:
   * **A Year-Long or Rolling Submissions Period**. "Many shady festivals may keep their submissions period going for a really long time, even a whole year," Wong writes. "They’ll also list a ton of deadlines, which is a way to keep their festival listing at the top of Film Freeway and Withoutabox. … A year-round submission process is more likely to be managed poorly, or simply an attempt to take in as many as possible."((Henry Wong, [[https://inkspire.org/post/scam-festivals-signs-of-a-fake-film-festival/-KqebuOXEPf-0fTG6vRd|"Scam Festivals: Signs of a Fake Film Festival"]], Inkspire website, 1/10/18.))   * **A Year-Long or Rolling Submissions Period**. "Many shady festivals may keep their submissions period going for a really long time, even a whole year," Wong writes. "They’ll also list a ton of deadlines, which is a way to keep their festival listing at the top of Film Freeway and Withoutabox. … A year-round submission process is more likely to be managed poorly, or simply an attempt to take in as many as possible."((Henry Wong, [[https://inkspire.org/post/scam-festivals-signs-of-a-fake-film-festival/-KqebuOXEPf-0fTG6vRd|"Scam Festivals: Signs of a Fake Film Festival"]], Inkspire website, 1/10/18.))
   * **Huge Number of Awards**. "Awards only have meaning and merit if they are hard to get," says Wong. "A high quantity of awards diminishes its impact and often feels more like a bait to reel in filmmakers."((Henry Wong, [[https://inkspire.org/post/scam-festivals-signs-of-a-fake-film-festival/-KqebuOXEPf-0fTG6vRd|"Scam Festivals: Signs of a Fake Film Festival"]], Inkspire website, 1/10/18.))   * **Huge Number of Awards**. "Awards only have meaning and merit if they are hard to get," says Wong. "A high quantity of awards diminishes its impact and often feels more like a bait to reel in filmmakers."((Henry Wong, [[https://inkspire.org/post/scam-festivals-signs-of-a-fake-film-festival/-KqebuOXEPf-0fTG6vRd|"Scam Festivals: Signs of a Fake Film Festival"]], Inkspire website, 1/10/18.))
- 
 ==== Axanar's Awards ==== ==== Axanar's Awards ====
  
Line 113: Line 122:
  
 The Nevada Film Festival was specifically identified as a "questionable entity" in IndieWire's investigation.((Jason Guerrasio, [[https://web.archive.org/web/20170717143630/http://www.indiewire.com/2013/01/an-iw-investigation-the-dark-underbelly-of-the-festival-circuit-part-2-241632/|"An IW Investigation: The Dark Underbelly of the Festival Circuit, Part 2"]], IndieWire, 1/17/13, retrieved from archive.org 2/4/18.)) The Nevada Film Festival was specifically identified as a "questionable entity" in IndieWire's investigation.((Jason Guerrasio, [[https://web.archive.org/web/20170717143630/http://www.indiewire.com/2013/01/an-iw-investigation-the-dark-underbelly-of-the-festival-circuit-part-2-241632/|"An IW Investigation: The Dark Underbelly of the Festival Circuit, Part 2"]], IndieWire, 1/17/13, retrieved from archive.org 2/4/18.))
 +
 +----
 +<WRAP>
 +//**__ More than one-third of //Prelude//'s awards may have come from these 'award factories,' which represent 42 percent of the sources of the film's honors.__**//
 +</WRAP>
  
 The remaining three questionable festivals were a mix of awards and some kind of public event: \\ The remaining three questionable festivals were a mix of awards and some kind of public event: \\
Line 120: Line 134:
  
 The last two appear to be set up for filmmakers to pay to get an award, which is then presented at a live event. It was difficult to confirm whether the "festivals" hold any public screenings. The Annual Widescreen event did appear to hold some screenings in addition to its award event, but it could not be confirmed if every award-winner received a screening, as they do at traditional festivals. The last two appear to be set up for filmmakers to pay to get an award, which is then presented at a live event. It was difficult to confirm whether the "festivals" hold any public screenings. The Annual Widescreen event did appear to hold some screenings in addition to its award event, but it could not be confirmed if every award-winner received a screening, as they do at traditional festivals.
 +
 +[{{ ::award_plaque_sponsoredby_axanar_productions_.jpg?direct&400|**SPONSORED BY** After winning six awards at this event, Peters paid to have Axanar Productions appear on every plaque awarded the following year. <wrap indent><wrap lo>//Photo/Treklanta. Click image to view full size//</wrap></wrap>}}]
  
 === Festivals Delegated to Axanar Fan === === Festivals Delegated to Axanar Fan ===
  
-According to Axanar spokesman Bawden, Peters himself did not handle the festival submission process.  "An Axanar fan … took on the responsibility for submitting entries and tracking them," Bawden told **AxaMonitor**. On Axanar's PR website, the fan was identified as a volunteer, Horus Austin.+According to Axanar spokesman Bawden, Peters himself did not handle the festival submission process.  "An Axanar fan … took on the responsibility for submitting entries and tracking them," Bawden told **AxaMonitor**. On Axanar's PR website, the fan was identified as a volunteer, Horace Austin.
  
 === The Remaining Awards === === The Remaining Awards ===
  
 The remaining awards for //Prelude to Axanar// did appear to come from legitimate film festivals, though The Zone, which gave //Prelude// six of its awards, now explicitly states fan films are no longer eligible, having created a separate festival for them. The remaining awards for //Prelude to Axanar// did appear to come from legitimate film festivals, though The Zone, which gave //Prelude// six of its awards, now explicitly states fan films are no longer eligible, having created a separate festival for them.
 +
 +==== Independent Star Trek Fan Film Awards ====
 +
 +Six of //Prelude//'s awards — the largest single set of its honors — came from the one award event, the inaugural [[http://treklanta.org/fanfilmawards2016.htm|Independent Star Trek Fan Film Awards]],  operated by the Treklanta convention, which honors Trek fan films. The following year, Peters sponsored the event, winning the naming rights for Axanar on each award plaque. {{:axamonitor-ico.gif?nolink|}}
  
 ---- ----
 //Additional reporting by Jody Wheeler// //Additional reporting by Jody Wheeler//
 +
 +<WRAP tip 75%>
 +<wrap em>COMMENTS</wrap> \\
 +Discuss this article in [[face>groups/axamonitor/permalink/336101163571404/|AxaMonitor's Facebook group]].
 +</WRAP>
  
 ---- ----
-**Keywords** {{tag>Prelude_to_Axanar fan_films film_festivals awards}}+**Keywords** {{tag>Prelude_to_Axanar fan_films film_festivals awards fact_check}}